One report can contain several different questions
Are vehicles with more alerts more likely to have an incident? Are losses higher once an incident occurs? Which behavior is associated with a safety score? Each question needs distinct variables, samples and methods. Placing the figures side by side does not make them the same relationship.
If alert information is already part of a score, explain that overlap when examining the correlation between alerts and the score. Part of the observed association may follow from the calculation itself.
Show the denominators
In a wholly synthetic example, 5 of the 100 subjects in group A experienced the event of interest. In group B, 3 of 20 did. The proportions are 5% and 15%, respectively. These values alone do not establish that group membership caused the difference in risk.
Check whether the observation periods, mileage, task types and grouping rules are comparable. A few events can shift the proportion substantially in a small group. Show counts and rates together, and identify missing data.
Correlation leaves the causal question open
Correlation describes how variables change together. It cannot on its own show that changing one will change the other. Road conditions, workload, vehicle type and record quality may all affect what you observe.
Name both variables, their units of analysis and the sample. An association between alert count and claim payout cannot be restated as “safety scores predict payouts.” Changing a variable changes the claim.
Turn recommendations into testable hypotheses
The analysis can suggest further checks, such as reviewing unusual records for quality, comparing task conditions or improving category definitions. Keep these suggestions provisional. They do not establish grounds for action against an individual driver.
To evaluate a management intervention, design a comparable baseline, observation period and metrics in advance, and account for operational changes. Issuing a recommendation provides no evidence that it has already had an effect.
What to include in a verifiable chart
- Exact variable names, units, period and sample scope.
- Grouping rules, counts and denominators for each group.
- Treatment of missing records, outliers and duplicates.
- A distinction between the observed relationship, proposed explanations and suggested actions.
